Pastel vs BugHerd
Pastel and BugHerd both let people comment on a live website without an account, but they’re aimed at different moments. Pastel is for collecting client feedback on sites and creative files. BugHerd is for QA: every comment becomes a task with technical details on a board.
Details checked November 14, 2026 from each company’s pricing page and help docs. We make edits.io, which appears as a third option below; we’re not affiliated with Pastel or BugHerd.
Best for
Pastel
Client feedback on websites, images, PDFs and video.
Best for
BugHerd
Website QA and bug tracking with a built-in task board.
Pastel vs BugHerd at a glance
| Feature | Pastel | BugHerd | edits.io (ours) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes: 1 user, 1 active canvas | No (7-day trial) | Yes: 3 GB storage, 10 projects, no time limit |
| Paid plans from | $29/month billed yearly or $35 monthly (Pro: 2 users, 3 canvases) | $42/month billed yearly or $50 monthly (Standard: 5 members) | $19/month flat (Pro), unlimited teammates and projects |
| Images | Yes | Yes (also Figma designs) | Yes: PNG, JPEG, WebP, SVG |
| Video | Yes, timestamped comments | No review of uploaded videos (reviewers can record 1-minute screen videos) | Yes: comments pinned to a spot on the frame and a timestamp |
| Yes | Yes | Yes: comments pinned to a spot on a page | |
| Websites | Live site through Pastel’s proxy, with a responsive tester | Live site via browser extension or a script on the site | Full-page screenshot of a public URL (no live-site commenting) |
| Reviewers without an account | Yes, name and email, no account | Yes, no account or login | Yes: guests comment under a name, no account |
Prices are in US dollars as shown on each pricing page (some vary by region) and may change. Check usepastel.com and bugherd.com for current plans.
How they differ
Setup
Pastel loads the site through its proxy, so there’s nothing to install. BugHerd works through a browser extension or a script added to the site.
Technical details
BugHerd records the browser, operating system, screen size and element with each comment and puts it on a Kanban board. Pastel focuses on the comment and the review round rather than technical data.
Video
Pastel reviews uploaded video with timestamped comments. BugHerd doesn’t review uploaded videos; reviewers can record 1-minute screen videos instead.
Price
Pastel has a free plan; Pro is $29 a month billed yearly or $35 monthly for 2 users. BugHerd has a 7-day trial; Standard is $42 a month billed yearly or $50 monthly for 5 members.
Choose Pastel if…
- You’re collecting feedback from clients during design and build.
- You also review videos.
- You want a free plan and nothing to install.
Choose BugHerd if…
- You’re testing a site before launch and want bug reports with technical details.
- You want feedback managed as tasks on a board or sent to your issue tracker.
- You need 5 team members on the entry plan.
Where edits.io fits
If your feedback is mostly on designs, PDFs and videos, with websites reviewed as full-page captures, edits.io covers it on a free plan or $19 a month for unlimited teammates. It doesn’t comment on live sites or capture technical data.
Frequently asked questions
Does Pastel or BugHerd need anything installed?+
Pastel doesn’t: it loads the site through a proxy. BugHerd uses a browser extension or a script on the site.
Which has a free plan?+
Pastel has a free plan with 1 user and 1 active canvas. BugHerd has a 7-day trial.
Which is better for bug reports?+
BugHerd, because it records browser, OS, screen size and the element with each comment and tracks them as tasks.
Sources for Pastel
- Plans, prices (monthly/annual), users/canvases, unlimited reviewers without account, proxy technology, free plan rules, 14-day trial: usepastel.com/plans
- Video comments tied to timestamps; video on all plans; storage per plan incl. Free 2 GB: help.usepastel.com/en/articles/12084757-review-videos-in-pastel
- File types (images, PDFs, video), no extensions needed, guests enter name/email without account: usepastel.com/faq
- Works on websites, images, PDFs; 'No login needed': usepastel.com
Sources for BugHerd
- Plans, prices, members, storage, USD, feature matrix (websites, Figma, PDFs, images): bugherd.com/pricing
- No accounts/log-ins for clients; extension vs JS snippet; 7-day trial; guest vs member roles: bugherd.com
- Images, PDFs, Figma deliverables: bugherd.com/feature/feedback-on-design-and-deliverables
- Video feedback = 1-minute screen recordings: bugherd.com/feature/video-feedback
- No login required for clients; snippet or Chrome extension: bugherd.com/visual-feedback-tool
More comparisons
Pastel vs MarkUp.io
Pastel and MarkUp.io both let clients comment directly on live websites, images, PDFs and video without an account.
Ruttl vs Pastel
Ruttl and Pastel both let clients comment on live websites, images and PDFs without signing up.
BugHerd vs Marker.io
BugHerd and Marker.io both turn feedback on a live website into bug reports, and neither has a free plan.
Want something simpler?
edits.io: pinned comments on images, PDFs, video and page captures. Free for 10 projects; reviewers never need an account.
Create a free account