Compare visual feedback tools
Head-to-head comparisons of review and proofing tools, using details from each company’s own pricing page and help docs (checked November 2026). We make edits.io, so it appears as a third option and we say when it isn’t the right fit.
The best visual feedback tools, by what you need
Eleven tools grouped by the job they do best, with free plans and starting prices side by side.
Tool vs tool
Pastel vs MarkUp.io
Pastel and MarkUp.io both let clients comment directly on live websites, images, PDFs and video without an account.
Filestage vs Ziflow
Filestage and Ziflow are both online proofing platforms for teams with formal approval processes, and their entry paid plans cost the same: $199 a month billed yearly or $249 monthly.
BugHerd vs Marker.io
BugHerd and Marker.io both turn feedback on a live website into bug reports, and neither has a free plan.
Frame.io vs Filestage
Frame.io, owned by Adobe, is built around professional video review.
Pastel vs BugHerd
Pastel and BugHerd both let people comment on a live website without an account, but they’re aimed at different moments.
Ruttl vs Pastel
Ruttl and Pastel both let clients comment on live websites, images and PDFs without signing up.